Self defence law in England and Wales is more permissive than many people assume in one respect and considerably stricter in another. This is general information rather than legal advice.
What does the law allow?
A person may use such force as is reasonable in the circumstances in defence of themselves or another, in defence of property, or in the prevention of crime. That principle comes from the common law and from section three of the Criminal Law Act 1967, and section seventy six of the Criminal Justice and Immigration Act 2008 sets out how it is applied.
How is reasonable judged?
Against the circumstances as the person honestly believed them to be, even if that belief turns out to be mistaken. The law also recognises that someone acting in a moment of unexpected anguish cannot be expected to weigh the exact measure of necessary action, and that evidence of doing what they honestly and instinctively thought was necessary is strong evidence that it was reasonable.
- Reasonable force is permitted in defence of self, others and property
- Judged on the facts as you honestly believed them to be
- You do not have to wait to be struck first
- There is no legal duty to retreat, though it is a relevant factor
- Force used once the danger has passed is not self defence
- Carrying anything for protection is a separate offence
Do you have to wait to be hit?
No. Pre emptive force is lawful where you honestly believe an attack is imminent, and there is no requirement to allow the first blow to land. Equally there is no legal duty to retreat, although whether you had the opportunity to withdraw is one of the factors a court would consider when assessing whether the force used was reasonable.
When does it stop being self defence?
When the threat has ended. Force used against someone who is no longer a danger, who is retreating or who is incapacitated is not defence but retaliation, and it is prosecuted as an assault. This is the point at which people most commonly cross from being a victim to being a defendant, and it is a genuine and frequent outcome.
What is different in your own home?
The threshold is higher. In householder cases, meaning a person in a dwelling using force against a trespasser, force that was disproportionate may still be lawful, and only grossly disproportionate force is automatically unreasonable. That is a meaningful protection and it does not mean anything is permitted, since the court still assesses whether the force was reasonable in all the circumstances.
What about carrying something?
This is where the law is strict, and it catches people out. Under the Prevention of Crime Act 1953 it is an offence to have an offensive weapon in a public place, and an offensive weapon includes any article intended by the person carrying it for causing injury. Carrying an ordinary object specifically for self defence therefore makes it an offensive weapon, whatever it is.
What about sprays?
Illegal to possess. Sprays such as CS and pepper are classed as prohibited weapons under section five of the Firearms Act 1968, because they are designed for the discharge of a noxious substance. Possession carries a substantial prison sentence, and buying one online or bringing one back from abroad is a serious criminal offence rather than a technicality.
What should you take from this?
That the law will support genuine defensive action taken in the moment, and that preparing for it by carrying something will not be supported at all. The practical conclusion is to concentrate on awareness, avoidance and leaving, which are lawful, effective and available to everyone.
Does it differ across the UK?
The principles are broadly similar and the statutory detail is not. Scotland has its own common law of self defence, which is somewhat stricter in places and includes a stronger expectation of retreating where that is possible, and Northern Ireland has separate legislation. Anyone relying on the specifics should take advice for their own jurisdiction rather than assuming the English position applies.
Reasonable force in the moment is lawful, judged on what you honestly believed, and carrying anything for protection is a separate offence in itself.