Filters solve one problem extremely well and are blind to another entirely. Understanding the boundary is what keeps people from treating water that should have been left alone.
Why can filters not remove dissolved substances?
Because filtration works by size. A membrane traps particles larger than its pores, and a dissolved metal ion, a salt or a pesticide molecule is orders of magnitude smaller than anything a portable filter blocks. They are not suspended in the water, they are part of it, and they pass through as freely as the water does.
What specifically gets through?
Salt, which is why filters cannot make seawater drinkable. Dissolved heavy metals including lead, arsenic, cadmium and zinc. Nitrates and phosphates from agricultural runoff. Most pesticides and industrial solvents, though carbon adsorbs a proportion. Radiological contamination. And viruses, in the case of ordinary zero point two micron filters.
- Salt, so seawater remains undrinkable
- Dissolved heavy metals from mining and industry
- Nitrates and agricultural chemicals
- Most solvents and industrial contamination
- Viruses, through ordinary filters
- Radiological contamination of any kind
Does boiling help instead?
It makes it worse. Boiling removes water as steam and leaves everything dissolved behind, so the concentration of metals, salts and nitrates rises in what remains. This is a genuinely counterintuitive point and an important one: for chemical contamination, boiling is actively harmful rather than merely useless.
What does deal with dissolved contamination?
Distillation and reverse osmosis, neither of which is realistically portable for emergency use. Distillation boils water and condenses the steam, leaving contaminants behind, which is why a solar still or a fire driven still can produce drinkable water from seawater. Reverse osmosis forces water through a membrane fine enough to exclude dissolved ions and requires pressure and equipment.
Where does this matter in Britain?
Former metal mining areas, principally mid Wales, the Pennines, Cornwall and the Lake District, where watercourses carry elevated lead, zinc, cadmium and arsenic from spoil heaps and adit drainage. The giveaway is ochre staining on the stream bed and stunted or absent bankside vegetation. Water in these catchments should be avoided rather than treated.
What else should be avoided outright?
Flood water, which mixes sewage, fuel and agricultural chemicals unpredictably. Water with an oily sheen, unusual colour, persistent foam or a chemical smell. Standing water near industrial land, landfill or intensive agriculture. Blue green algal blooms, whose toxins are destroyed neither by boiling nor by filtration. In each case the correct response is to find another source.
How do you judge a source?
By looking at the catchment rather than the water. What is upstream, what does the bank vegetation look like, is there aquatic life, and is there any industrial or mining history. Healthy fresh water supports visible invertebrates, and their absence is a meaningful warning. Source selection is the part of water safety that treatment cannot rescue you from.
What is the practical conclusion?
Filters and tablets handle biology, and source selection handles chemistry. Choose the source carefully first, treat it second, and accept that some water cannot be made safe with anything you can carry. That ordering is the whole of the subject.
What about hardness and minerals?
They pass through and are generally harmless. Calcium and magnesium, which make water hard, are dissolved minerals that no portable filter removes and that cause no health problem, only limescale and a different taste. Some carbon and ion exchange products soften water for taste and appliance reasons. This is a comfort question rather than a safety one and should not be confused with contamination.
How do you spot chemical trouble?
By reading the surroundings rather than the water. An oily sheen, unusual colouration, persistent foam that is not simply agitation, a chemical or sulphurous smell, orange staining on the stream bed and a conspicuous absence of plant and invertebrate life are all warnings. Healthy water supports visible life, and water that is strikingly sterile is usually sterile for a reason worth respecting.
Does any portable option handle salt?
Only distillation, realistically. Boiling seawater and condensing the steam produces genuinely fresh water, which is why a solar still or a fire driven still is the standard maritime survival answer. Portable reverse osmosis pumps exist for liferafts and are expensive and slow. No filter, no tablet and no ultraviolet device removes salt, and drinking seawater accelerates dehydration rather than relieving it.
Filters and boiling deal with organisms only, boiling concentrates chemicals, and chemical contamination is answered by choosing a different source.