The first decision determines most of what follows, and it is almost always the same: stop. Continuing to move while you work out what has happened is how small problems become large ones.
Why stop?
Because movement while confused takes you further from where you last knew your position, uses energy you may need, and prevents clear thinking. People who are lost, injured or caught out consistently keep going, driven by the destination and by the discomfort of admitting a problem. Almost every account of a bad outcome includes a period of pressing on.
What does stopping involve?
Physically stopping, sitting down if appropriate, and deliberately taking a few minutes. Put a layer on before you cool, have a drink and something to eat, and let your heart rate settle. The old mnemonic of stop, think, observe and plan captures it, and the first word is the one that does the work.
- Stop moving physically and deliberately
- Put a layer on before you cool down
- Eat and drink something, which improves thinking
- Establish what has actually happened
- Check the time, the weather and the daylight remaining
- Decide, then act, rather than acting and then deciding
What should you establish?
Four things. What has actually gone wrong, stated plainly. Where you are, or the last point at which you knew. What resources you have, including people, equipment, daylight and phone battery. And what the weather is doing. Those four determine every subsequent decision and most people have not consciously assembled them.
Why does eating help?
Because cold, tired and hungry people make poor decisions, and the effect is larger than people expect. Blood sugar affects judgement and mood measurably, and a person who has eaten and drunk something thinks more clearly ten minutes later. It also generates heat. It feels like a delay and it is the fastest route to a better decision.
How long should you take?
Five or ten minutes, which feels like an eternity when something is wrong and is almost always the right investment. The exceptions are genuine immediate danger such as a casualty who is bleeding heavily, an unstable slope or rising water, where you deal with the hazard first and then stop properly.
What should you decide?
One thing at a time, with a clear reason. Are we staying or moving. Are we calling for help. Are we getting shelter up. Decide, tell everyone, and do it. The most common failure in groups is a decision nobody actually made, where everyone assumes something is agreed and half the party is doing something else.
Who should decide?
One person, and in a group that should be agreed rather than assumed. Groups make notably worse decisions than individuals under stress when nobody is nominated, since everyone defers and the least considered option prevails by default. Someone saying clearly what is going to happen is worth a great deal.
What if you are on your own?
The same, said out loud. Talking through the situation audibly is a well recognised technique used by pilots and mountaineers, and it genuinely improves the quality of thinking under stress by forcing you to articulate rather than spiral. It feels absurd and it works.
What if it is dark or you are already cold?
Do the protection first and think afterwards. Where someone is already shivering or the light has gone, getting a shelter up and layers on comes before the assessment, because thinking degrades as you cool and the situation worsens while you deliberate. Warm, sheltered people make better decisions, so buy yourself the conditions to decide well.
What is the most useful question?
What is the worst that happens if we stop here now. Working that through usually reveals that a night out with shelter and layers is uncomfortable rather than dangerous, which removes the pressure driving people onward. Comparing that against the worst case of continuing, in darkness on unknown ground, generally makes the decision obvious.
Stop moving, put a layer on, eat something, work out what has happened and where you are, then decide one thing and act on it.